The truth is that we don’t know for sure the etiology of homosexuality — the reasons that some people are gay while most others are not. However, current scientific research leans toward the idea that people are born with the capacity to be either gay or straight and that the environment may have some influence as well. In spite of the research done on the subject, scientists have not found any conclusive results.
For many years, homosexuality was defined as a mental illness, and treatment was aimed at restoring “normal” sexuality. It wasn’t until 1973 that the American Psychiatric Association recognized that homosexuality wasn’t a mental illness. Here is what modern science has to say about homosexuality: Research with twins has demonstrated that a genetic component to homosexuality exists, but genetics isn’t thought to account for all cases.
Anatomical studies of the brain have shown some apparent structural differences between homosexuals and heterosexuals, but to date this research, while continuing, is still speculative.
Although humans have been contemplating the issue for eons, we still can come to no conclusion about what determines sexual orientation. All we know is that homosexuality among men and women has existed for as long as history has been recorded, that homosexual lifestyles are no more likely to disappear than heterosexual ones, and, as far as I’m concerned, that homosexuals should be treated with the same respect as every other human being.
Keeping religion and government out of the bedroom
Is knowing why some people live a different lifestyle important? In a perfectly open society that attached no consequences to one’s sexual orientation, knowing what caused different sexual orientations may not be important. But, because some people in our society publicly advocate that homosexual men and lesbians be prevented from — or even punished for — living their lifestyles, I think that understanding the reasons behind homosexuality is relevant.
You see, if gay people have a choice in their lifestyles, then some can perhaps legitimately argue that society should try to control how they live. (Some lesbians say that they chose lesbianism for political reasons, but that subject is beyond the scope of this book.) Society singles out a number of different modes of behavior to restrict. Some think that because we ban things such as prostitution and sex with minors, we could also ban homosexuality. Sodomy (a term that refers to anal sex but can also include oral sex) was illegal across the country for many years and is still outlawed in some states.
But what if sexual orientation is beyond our choice? What if we’re born with our sexual orientation and can’t change it? Should society pass laws forbidding homosexuals from having sex if that’s the only way that sex is pleasing to them? And the other question is, do we want the government telling us what to do in our bedrooms, no matter what our sexual orientation?
Now, as a Jew, I know that the Bible specifically bans homosexual acts, and therefore many believers in the Bible consider homosexuals to be sinners. The problem with relying on the Bible is that so much of what it says is open to interpretation. For example, just a few pages from where the Bible bans homosexual acts, it admonishes us not to wear clothes made from different types of cloth. How many of us follow that regulation? Some religious denominations, such as the Episcopalians, voice support for homosexual priests despite these Biblical injunctions. Many Christians also support our armed forces despite the fact that one of the Ten Commandments says “Thou shalt not kill” and Jesus instructed his followers to turn the other cheek. The only thing we know for certain is that we are all here on this Earth together.
In America, we believe in the separation between church and state. Believers in the Bible are certainly free to stop themselves from committing certain sexual acts, but under the U.S. Constitution, their beliefs don’t confer on them the right to force others to believe or behave as they do.
Although gay sexuality may not fit the mold used by most people, I believe that we shouldn’t criticize gays for behavior over which they may really have no control, and which doesn’t harm anyone anyway. Nobody forces anyone to be gay, and neither should anyone force someone not to be gay.
Behaving responsibly, no matter what orientation you are
What two consenting adults, whatever their sexual orientation, do in the privacy of their home is their own business. Now this doesn’t mean that I give blanket absolution to every form of homosexual behavior. For example, I believe that some of the activities that take place in public areas, like at gay bars and bathhouses, go too far — especially in this era of AIDS.
Homosexuals are as capable of responsible sex as are heterosexuals — and they’re just as capable of irresponsible sex as well. Considering that heterosexuals have a 50 percent divorce rate and often have multiple sexual partners over time, expecting homosexuals to be any different by picking one partner and staying with him or her for a lifetime is unreasonable.
A person in either lifestyle should make a serious effort to form a relationship before having sex. And all sexually active people — gay and straight — should employ safer sex practices.
Where does bisexuality fit in?
There are a few areas in my field where the jury is still out. I’ve already mentioned one of these, the G-spot orgasm. Another is the issue of bisexuality. There is no doubt that there are people who have sex with both the opposite sex and their own sex. What is open to question is whether this is a permanent state or a transitional one. Now, to people who consider themselves bisexual at any given point in time, it will seem as if this is how they will always feel, and yet research has shown that some bisexuals do end up becoming either heterosexual or homosexual. By the way, I’m not talking about who their specific partner is at the moment, but rather how they feel on the inside. Someone could never have had sex with a person of the same sex, say, but still feel the attraction.
Some people label themselves as bicurious, meaning that they want to try sex with both sexes, and may even have done so, but haven’t made up their mind as to their sexual orientation. What gives me pause about this concept is that there appears to be some peer pressure with regards to this, so young people are engaging in sexual acts just to be thought of as cool, rather than because they are really unsure of where they stand. Because I strongly believe that you should only have sex with someone with whom you share a romantic relationship, and because having sex with multiple partners incurs risks, I would urge you not to experiment simply out of curiosity.
Just as we don’t know everything there is to know about homosexuality, we also can’t close the books on bisexuality either. I hope that one day conclusive research will be done on the remaining open issues so we can help people to not only understand, but accept people’s various sexual orientations. Determining Your Orientation: What Turns You On I’m sure that many heterosexuals are reading this chapter out of curiosity, and that’s great. Some straight readers may even get turned on by reading about gay sex, which may confuse them. They may suddenly start to wonder whether they themselves are gay. So, before getting to the sexual part of this discussion, I’d like to familiarize you with the very beginning of the process — uncovering your sexual orientation. Getting excited by reading about homosexual sex, or even having fantasies about engaging in sexual relations with a member of your own sex, doesn’t mean that you’re gay. A homosexual definitely knows whether he or she is attracted to members of their own sex, and that identification doesn’t come because of an occasional gay fantasy. In addition to gay fantasies, a common occurrence among young teen males is to sexually experiment with another male. This experimentation may take the form of masturbating together, or actually masturbating each other.
This may occur among females, too. This type of behavior doesn’t usually go any further than that. Again, sexual experimentation among teenagers is pretty common and doesn’t indicate any homosexual tendencies.What does indicate that a young person is actually a homosexual? The best indicator of homosexuality is if you can get sexually excited only by thinking about having sex with someone of your own sex (even if you have sex only with members of the opposite sex).
Revealing Your Sexual Identity
Sexual orientation goes beyond just engaging in sexual acts. A person’s sexual identity will cover a broad range of areas, some of which may because by sexual orientation, or may simply be a way of fitting in with others in a group. Is being a football fan primarily a straight man’s hobby, or having a flair for fashion primarily a gay man’s interest? I don’t know the answers, but I do know that some people behave in particular ways so they can blend in with their chosen community. So sexual identity affects many aspects of a person’s life, including sexual behavior, sexual attraction, affection, safety, socialization, and so on.
Living in the closet
Saying that someone is in the closet has a range of meanings. Basically, the phrase refers to someone who doesn’t openly admit that he or she is gay. Some people who get married, have children, and spend an entire lifetime living with and regularly having sex with a member of the opposite sex are really not heterosexual at all. To get excited, these people have to fantasize about having sex with a member of their own sex.
People who appear to be openly heterosexual may actually lead clandestine gay sex lives in several different ways:
- Some people visit gay bars when the opportunity presents itself, go to areas where gay prostitutes are known to hang out, or merely masturbate while looking at gay magazines.
- Some people lead a gay lifestyle only when in the presence of other gays, but put on a front of being heterosexual in other settings, such as at work or school.
- Some people may never actually engage in any form of gay sex, but, nevertheless, deep down inside, are gay.
Many of these people, especially in today’s more liberal atmosphere, do end up “coming out of the closet” at some point in their lives. Others box themselves in so tightly that they just don’t feel that they can survive the revelation, and so they hide their homosexuality for their entire lives.
Coming out
Before 1969, few gays publicly revealed their sexual orientation (also called coming out), but a riot in New York — caused by a police raid of a gay bar called The Stonewall — politicized many gays and started what was called the Gay Liberation Movement. This movement insists that those in society treat the homosexual lifestyle the same as the heterosexual one, and that people give gays rights equal to those of everyone else. Since then, federal, state, and city legislatures have passed many laws that give gays much more freedom than they once had to practice their lifestyles. Nevertheless, many members of our society still frown on gays — oftentimes, including the people who are closest to gays: their families.
Coming out to family and friends
The adolescent years are never easy for anyone, but they’re certainly a lot more difficult for gay young people. Not only do gay teens have to confront their own emerging sexuality, which is different from that of most of their peers, but they must then face the rebuke that their sexuality often brings from their immediate families. Revealing one’s homosexuality is never easy — for young or old — but the process can be particularly difficult for teens, who are dependent on their families and have not yet established their own private lives with their own place to live and a job to provide financial support. In fact, the rates of suicide for young homosexuals are much higher than for heterosexuals of the same age, in great part because many can’t cope when faced with rejection from their families.
No two families react the same way when a son or a daughter comes out of the closet.
Some parents may have suspected their child’s homosexual orientation for a while and learned to accept it, so they have a general sense of relief that the subject is out in the open.
Other parents react very negatively, upset that many of their expectations for their child — the traditional heterosexual marriage followed by grandchildren — have suddenly disappeared. They may also react negatively, in part because they feel that their child’s homosexuality reflects badly on them (and the way they raised that child) in the eyes of the rest of the family as well as friends and neighbors.
In some families, the reaction is split, with one parent accepting the son or daughter’s announcement and the other going so far as to cut off all contact.
Teens should understand that being a parent isn’t easy, and because the expectations of most parents are turned topsy-turvy by the announcement that their child is gay, it’s normal for them to have some mixed emotions in the beginning. Getting past those feelings and working with your parents, and perhaps a counselor, to rebuild family unity is the key, and I don’t believe that you can help do that without some preparation. If you’re forewarned about how your family may react, and have been told ways to handle these reactions, you’re much more likely to end up being accepted by your family.
The most important advice I can give to those of you who are gay and who haven’t revealed your sexual identity to your family is to immediately find a counselor who has worked with other gay people facing this problem to give you. The counselor’s experience in this area can be invaluable to you in obtaining the best possible results from your circumstances.
Coming out to the world
Most gay people come out to a potential sex partner first. That experience itself can be very scary. What if that person turns out to be straight? Rejection is always traumatic, but especially if the other person is actually repulsed by the offer, as a straight person approached sexually by someone of their own sex often is.
Eventually, most gay people meet others who share their lifestyle, and the support that they get from others helps them to then declare their sexual orientation to their families and friends. One new way of discussing the topic that is helping many teens come out are Internet chat rooms. Using this method of communication, teens can find out about the gay lifestyle without having to reveal their own identity until they’re ready to do so.
Coming out in your profession or on the job can be much more risky. Openness about one’s sexual orientation doesn’t always translate well in the business world. Because of this, many gay people who don’t hide their status at home are very careful about whom they tell at the office. Some companies won’t hire a homosexual simply because of the strain that a potentially HIV-positive person may put on their health benefits program. In other cases, some employers are becoming less tolerant of their homosexual employees, either because of their own fear of AIDS or because of a concern that their other employees may react negatively. Even though this discrimination is often illegal, it doesn’t stop it from occurring, no matter how abhorrent.
This on-the-job discrimination against homosexuals can backfire in the battle against AIDS. For appearance’s sake, a gay employee may avoid forming a relationship, which forces him or her into the dangerous world of anonymous sex, where the risk of getting and spreading AIDS is so much higher.
Because a gay person can never know exactly what the outcome of his or her coming out will be, the decision is always a heavy burden. If everything goes right, gay men and women may feel as though a tremendous weight has been lifted from their shoulders because they no longer have to lead dual lives. On the other hand, if they end up losing contact with certain family members and friends or losing their job, many people may find the loss a heavy price to pay for admitting their true identity.
Coming out when you’re married, with children The gay man or woman who marries someone of the opposite sex and also has children faces a double burden if he or she decides to reveal a different sexual identity. In addition to his or her own suffering, his or her partner and children undoubtedly suffer tremendously.
Although the gay person certainly feels a sense of loss at leaving the spouse and children, the gay person will likely eventually blossom within the gay community. However, for the partner who is left behind, the grieving process can be worse than that caused by the death of a spouse. That person now has not only lost a spouse, but has also had his or her own sexual worth badly damaged. The partner whom they loved, and whom they thought found them sexually attractive, may have never actually felt that way. This realization comes as a crushing blow. (However, some women are relieved to know that they were being rejected for reasons that had nothing to do with them as individuals.) Straight spouse support groups can help people come to terms with their thoughts about themselves and their gay spouses. Still, many abandoned spouses end up facing their loss alone.
These negative consequences don’t result from the gay people making a bad decision by coming out. Rather, I believe that these gay people make a bad decision when they marry in the first place. By allowing society to pressure them into leading a lifestyle that doesn’t suit them, they end up causing many other people a lot of pain and suffering later on — in addition to the suffering they endure themselves while leading a life not truly their own.
Outing by others
Some people within the gay community believe that all gay people should reveal their homosexuality. These people sometimes act on this belief and reveal the secretly gay person’s sexual orientation to the world at large in a process called outing.
I am totally against outing. I have seen the pain and suffering that gay people go through when they freely decide to reveal their true selves, and nobodyhas the right to force someone else to undergo that process.
Finding support
Not long ago, left-handed children were forced to learn to write with their right hands. Society has since learned to accept lefties, and in some endeavors, such as sports, many lefties actually have an advantage.
I hope one day we will feel the same way about gay people that we feel about lefties. The pressures that our society puts on gays to keep their sexuality hidden causes untold damage. And the guilt for this lies not on gay people, but on all of us for trying to force them into adopting a false sexual identity.
Although everyone focuses on the AIDS crisis among homosexuals — and the disease certainly has had a horrible effect on this population — at the same time, gays have been building networks to help each other live more satisfying lives. They’ve organized politically, with groups such as the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force, so that in major cities with large gay communities, homosexuals have gained many, if not most, of the same civil rights as heterosexuals. Gay resorts have sprung up where homosexuals can gather without feeling different.
All of these changes have made life a lot more pleasant for homosexuals since the Stonewall incident, but far too many people still remain ignorant and discriminate against others because of their sexual orientation.